Is Italian Nutella Really Better Than American Nutella?

Is Italian Nutella Really Better Than American Nutella?

Background and History

Nutella, the beloved hazelnut chocolate spread, originated in Italy in the 1960s. It was created by Pietro Ferrero, and its popularity quickly spread worldwide. However, there are debates about whether the original Italian Nutella surpasses its American counterpart. Let’s delve into the details to determine which version truly reigns supreme.


Italian Nutella

Sugar, palm oil, hazelnuts, cocoa solids, milk powder, lecithin (an emulsifier), and vanillin (an artificial flavor).

American Nutella

Sugar, palm oil, hazelnuts, cocoa solids, milk powder, soy lecithin (an emulsifier), and vanillin (an artificial flavor).


Depends on personal preference and usage.


Preparation: 5 minutes

Tasting: Allow time for comparison.

Cooking Time

Not applicable; Nutella is ready to use.


Choose Your Nutella

Purchase both Italian and American Nutella jars from your local grocery store.

Examine the Labels

Read the ingredient list and nutritional information on each jar to compare the subtle differences.

Texture and Appearance

Observe the texture and color of each Nutella. Italian Nutella is often said to have a smoother texture and a darker, richer color.

Taste Test

Conduct a blind taste test to evaluate flavor nuances. Note any variations in sweetness, nuttiness, or overall richness.

Pairing Options

Enjoy Nutella with bread, pancakes, waffles, or fresh fruit to discern how each complements different foods.

Nutrition Facts

Both versions generally have similar nutritional profiles, with slight variations in ingredients and ratios.


Preferences for Nutella can be subjective, so trust your taste buds to determine the winner.

Consider factors like personal taste, texture preference, and the intended use of Nutella (spread, dip, or ingredient in recipes).

Allergy Warning

Both Italian and American Nutella contain hazelnuts and milk. Be cautious if you have allergies to these ingredients.

Percival Langley
Latest posts by Percival Langley (see all)
Percival Langley, the creative force behind this site, holds the unique and delectable title of Gourmet Expert. With a passion for elevating the culinary experiences of our furry companions, Percival shares delightful and nutritious recipes that go beyond the ordinary. His site is a go-to resource for pet owners seeking to pamper their pets with gourmet treats and meals. Percival's expertise in crafting delicious and health-conscious pet cuisine is evident in the tasteful and innovative content he curates. For those who believe in treating their pets to a culinary adventure, Percival Langley's site is a flavorful journey into the world of gourmet pet delights.